The quiet neighborhood in the Catalina Foothills of Arizona has been filled with worry and questions since 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie disappeared from her home. As days have turned into weeks, small details have started to stand out — including something unusual noticed by a neighbor and his dogs.
A man named Jeff Lamie, who lives just a few houses away, says his dogs behaved in a strange way on two nights connected to the case. According to him, the animals suddenly woke him up in the middle of the night — something they almost never do.
Lamie shared his experience during an interview on Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. While he admits the behavior could mean nothing, he also believes it might be important.
A Strange Night in February
Lamie says the first unusual incident happened around 1 a.m. on February 1. This is the same time investigators believe Nancy Guthrie may have been taken from her home.
He explained that his dogs suddenly became restless and woke him up. Normally, they sleep through the night without any problems. One of them, he said, is usually such a deep sleeper that it takes a lot to wake it.
But that night was different.
“They don’t usually act like that,” Lamie said. “It was not normal at all.”
Because the dogs seemed so alert, he decided to take them outside. He expected to see or hear something unusual, but the neighborhood was quiet.
“I didn’t hear anything, I didn’t see anything,” he explained. “But animals can sense things we can’t.”
Even though nothing seemed out of place to him, the dogs’ behavior stayed in his mind.
Looking Back at Security Footage
Later, Lamie reviewed footage from his home security cameras. What he saw made him even more curious.
In the video, one of his dogs appeared to stop and stare at something far away. The animal seemed focused, almost like it noticed movement or a sound. After a few moments, the dog moved on.
Lamie could not tell what the dog was reacting to. There was nothing clearly visible in the footage. Still, the moment stood out.
“It could be nothing,” he said. “But it could also be something we just don’t understand.”
Another Night Raises Questions
What makes the situation more interesting is that this was not the only time the dogs acted this way.
Lamie said a similar incident happened earlier, on January 11.
Again, it was late at night. Again, the dogs suddenly woke him up. And again, their behavior seemed unusual and out of place.
At the time, he did not think much of it. But later, when investigators started focusing on that date, it caught his attention.
A Key Date in the Investigation
Authorities have recently pointed to January 11 as an important date in the case.
Sheriff Chris Nanos, who is leading the investigation, said they believe “something happened” at Nancy Guthrie’s home that night. However, he has not shared exactly what evidence led them to that conclusion.
This statement has raised many questions. What could have happened two weeks before her disappearance? Was someone watching the house? Was there an earlier attempt to break in?
Investigators have not given clear answers yet.
But when Lamie realized his dogs had acted strangely on that exact night, he felt it was important to speak up.
Sharing Information with Police
Lamie said he immediately reported everything to investigators.
“I don’t know if it helps,” he explained. “But we wanted to share anything that might matter.”
Police have been asking neighbors to check their security cameras and report anything unusual. Even small details could help build a timeline.
Lamie also went back through footage from other dates the police asked about. He wanted to see if there were any patterns or repeated behaviors.
So far, he has not found anything else unusual.
Dogs and Their Senses
Many people believe dogs can sense things humans cannot. They can hear sounds from far away and detect smells that are impossible for people to notice.
This is why Lamie thinks his dogs’ behavior could be meaningful.
“Dogs are very sensitive,” he said. “They pick up on things we don’t even realize are there.”
At the same time, he is careful not to jump to conclusions. He understands that animals can sometimes react to small or harmless things.
“It could just be a coincidence,” he admitted.
No More Strange Behavior
One detail that stands out is that the dogs have not acted this way since those two nights.
Lamie said their behavior returned to normal immediately afterward. They have been sleeping through the night like they always did before.
That makes the incidents feel even more unusual.
“It hasn’t happened again,” he said. “That’s what makes it strange.”
A Community on Edge
The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie has deeply affected the neighborhood. People who once felt safe are now more cautious.
Neighbors are checking their cameras more often. Some have installed new security systems. Others are keeping a closer eye on their surroundings.
Everyone is hoping for answers.
Nancy Guthrie is the mother of television host Savannah Guthrie. Her family has been speaking out, asking for help from the public.
They are holding onto hope that she will be found.
Weeks Without Answers
As the search continues, frustration is growing.
It has been several weeks since Nancy Guthrie disappeared, and there are still many unanswered questions.
What happened on January 11?
What occurred in the early hours of February 1?
Did anyone see or hear something important?
Investigators are working to piece together a timeline, but they need more information.
The Importance of Small Clues
In cases like this, even the smallest details can matter.
Something that seems unimportant at first — like a dog barking or waking up — could become a key part of the investigation later.
That is why police are encouraging people to come forward with anything they remember.
Even if it seems minor, it could help connect the dots.
Hope for Answers
Lamie says he hopes his story will be useful in some way.
“I just want to help,” he said. “If this adds anything to the timeline, then it’s worth sharing.”
Like everyone else in the neighborhood, he wants to know what happened.
He also wants Nancy Guthrie to be found.
A Family Waiting
For Nancy Guthrie’s children, the wait has been especially difficult.
They have asked the public for help, hoping someone will come forward with new information.
Every day without answers is painful. But they continue to hope.
What Happens Next
The investigation is still ongoing.
Authorities are reviewing evidence, analyzing footage, and following leads. They are also continuing to speak with neighbors and gather information.
The mention of January 11 suggests there may be more to the story than initially thought.
If something did happen that night, it could be a key piece of the puzzle.
A Mystery That Remains
For now, the case remains unsolved.
The strange behavior of Lamie’s dogs is just one small part of a much larger mystery.
Was it a coincidence? Or did the animals sense something important?
No one knows for sure.
But in a case with so few clear answers, even the smallest clues matter.
Final Thoughts
The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie has left a community searching for answers and a family holding onto hope.
Stories like Lamie’s remind us that sometimes, the smallest details can make a difference.
A restless dog. A late-night walk. A moment caught on camera.
Any one of these could help solve the mystery.
Until then, neighbors remain alert, investigators continue their work, and a family waits for the day they finally learn what happened.
